A window into his mind
To show or not to show Cho Seung-Hui's "manifesto?" That was the question faced by NBC News. We did what I would think every responsible news organization would do.
I've seen and read through some of the documents that have never aired, because I've been reporting on it all day on MSNBC. It's unbelievable, just like the massacre. We're in the business of providing the public with information and letting you decide how to process it.
Given the enormity of what happened at Virginia Tech, given our failure to comprehend in any way, how someone could become so whatever it was that fueled Cho's rampage, his final words and pictures offer a window into his mind. Admittedly, so much of it in just an angry rant or diatribe, but it says something that perhaps helps us understand. Or at least helps us try to.
Perhaps there's something there that might set off alarms about the next Cho?
All day, I've seen and heard bits of what the gunman had to say. Each time I walk away feeling more and more upset about it. Shaking my head. I've never seen anything like it. Except perhaps the videos left behind by suicide bombers abroad. But what Cho left behind was so much more extensive. He'd thought about it, certainly in a delusional way, for a long time. I keep asking myself, how could someone actually murder people in cold blood, then walk to the post office and mail a package. And then kill so many many more. And I wonder why no one apparently saw him during the 2 hours, while he ran his murderous errand?
I haven't traveled to the campus in Blacksburg, Va., but now I feel in some ways I have. Perhaps those of you who've watched the pictures feel much the same. Perhaps you didn't want to go. I can honestly say I now feel a deeper sense of the tragedy there. I've seen more than my fair share of death and despair during 25 years in this business. You tend to detach after a while. You have to. The "manifesto" draws you close to Blacksburg. Hearing the killer's voice and seeing him dressed as his victims probably did really drives home in such stark relief the horror of those moments.
I would imagine most people in the Virginia Tech community turned away from the "manifesto." I'm only calling it that because I can't think of another word. Manifesto, frankly, is a word with too much dignity for the rankings of a deranged mass murderer. Some, I've heard say, watched, hoping to get another piece of the puzzle. There's something about having a lot of puzzle pieces that perhaps helps us deal with unspeakable grief and sorrow. Everyone deals with the impossible in their own way.
Finally, I hope Cho's voice and images remain in the nation's mind and heart, when we turn from Virginia Tech, to issues of what we should be learning from what's happened. Those lesson's will be part of the legacy left by the students and faculty cut down so much too soon. When we talk about violence in our culture, caring for the mentally ill or criminally insane, and dare I say it....gun control. If that multimedia diatribe serves any useful purpose, perhaps it will form some of the background noise for those debates, when we think about the worst possible consequences of hoping the tough issues just go away.
Read more from Ron Allen
DESCENDING INTO HELL
TRACKBACKS
Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451b0aa69e200d83453113069e2
As a student, the shootings at Virginia Tech were especially difficult. But the media attention on mental illness is simply perpetuating the stigma that all people with mental illness are crazy or likely to snap and hurt their classmates. IN FL, there are talks about increasing the university's capacity to expel mentally students. The school I attend, UF, would not have to do that if they did not turn away suicidal students or make it a school crime to have suicidal thoughts. This is a problem many people cannot help and need care, but are not dangerous to other students. By all means, I understand the impact this killer has caused on the lives of so many people. I would just like to see one member of the media take another position on the issue. I adore Ron Allen. As a journalism major, I have a sadly dim view of mainstream media. However, Mr. Allen is the exception -- he's brilliant. In this case, I just want him to think about the people whose rights may jeopardized because one person was off-the-chart. Need I reming America -- In some states felons can own guns, but Baker Act petients cannot! Where did their Secong Amendment rights go? As much as I hate to say it, I fear the VT shootings will begin a process of discrimination at universities. That includes the mentally ill, foreign students, and possibly African-Americans.
(Sent Apr 30, 2007 4:22:14 PM)
I visit a prison each week and have noticed the predomenence of left handed people there. i would be interested to know if the killer was right or left handed. Also, why was he so angry--what has been going on in his life.
(Sent Apr 23, 2007 12:01:07 AM)
The criteria of the tapes being news is not credible. A statement that the package had been received and had been given to law enforcement would be sufficient. Any information that would further the investigation could be reported, but to give screen time to a psychotic killer only encourages other potential psychotic killers. I think the Columbine murders was publicized too much. If someone wishes to see this diatribe, refer them to a library.
(Sent Apr 20, 2007 8:35:45 AM)
I believe NBC made a wise choice in airing the bits and pieces of a disturbed person. This answered the questions of millions of people, and every news organization. This was done with integrity and responsibility, by NBC.
Karen Smith, Temple, Texas (Sent Apr 19, 2007 8:52:25 PM)
I think it was terrible that this information was showed. The news media gave this very disturbed individual exactly what he wanted, to inspire others and explain the reasons behind his "martyrdom". Instead of doing this please give more attention to those victims who used their lives for good rather than giving evil a platform.
(Sent Apr 19, 2007 5:32:36 PM)
He got what he wanted, and others will follow. The good ole American culture that normal Americans have no control over, but have to live in the world it creates. The garbage should have been passed on to the cops, screened for anything useful to the case and burned.
Dave, Tn (Sent Apr 19, 2007 4:51:26 PM)
In regards to the airing of the VT shooter, I who has been in law enforcement all of my life, agree the material after careful editing should be made available.
In nearly each instance, (previous shootings) the term "bullied, picked on" comes up. Maybe, seriously doubt it, but maybe the people will start to understand, picking on someone who is quiet and to himself or who has a slightly different look or accent, now a days have grave results.
I applaud NBC, people need to see why this person attacked, hearing it from the shooter is more powerful than a paid correspondant telling us.
What could have been different if only one person had backed off. We will never know the full outcome, that was taken to the grave with Cho...but how soon will we forget this just like all of the others, including 911 until the next one happens...?
When will we learn...?
Len Crain Highland, IL. (Sent Apr 19, 2007 4:49:03 PM)
Completely unnecessary. NBC should be ashamed of ever considering this.
(Sent Apr 19, 2007 4:41:03 PM)
You should immediately stop showing the video of the killer on TV and on any of your web sites. You are giving a voice to someone who felt like he had no voice. There are countless of other people out there that feel the same way. In their minds you are putting the killer on a pedestal. Now people know his name, pay attention to him and he stands out in the crowd. Other troubled people see this and they see their chance to be above the rest, if only for a little while. You are opening the door for the copycats. Print the story, but leave out the video and the pictures.
(Sent Apr 19, 2007 4:36:56 PM)
The airing of the shooters' multimedia documents was surely the proper choice journalistically for NBC; some news is inherently painful -- and there's substantial value in the public understanding better the motives (and psychoses) of a ruthless killer, in order to better address such problems within our society.
On the other hand -- NBC should not turn over the public airwaves within its control to a killer and his paranoid ravings, if for no other reason so as to not to proffer "fifteen minutes of fame" to other troubled souls, if they too should commit such heinous crimes. I understand NBC News president Steve Capus has committed to not giving more than 10% of any NBC broadcast to this aspect of the tragic Virginia Tech story -- which is certainly an appropriate decision and even that level should quickly taper to nearly nothing.
I only wish such limits had been placed on the overblown Imus story last week, for a shock jock's troglodyte comments were only amplified through excessive repetition, whilst other important news went unreported.
John Hansen, Cambridge, Mass. (Sent Apr 19, 2007 4:28:42 PM)
SEND A COMMENT
PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to this post, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.