President Bush, Unplugged
Covering the White House, my colleagues and I listen carefully to every speech the President gives. We can often anticipate the stories and anecdotes he likes to share, but today we heard a few surprises.
The President has been taking questions from audiences at a few events recently. His advisers say they are not screened or scripted in advance as they often were during the campaign season. The best proof of that may well be in this exchange between the President and a man in the audience at Kansas State University.
QUESTION:
"You're a rancher. A lot of us here in Kansas are ranchers. I was just wanting to get your opinion on "Brokeback Mountain" if you've seen it yet."
(LAUGHTER)
"You would love it. You should check it out."
PRESIDENT BUSH: "I hadn't seen it. I'd be glad to talk about ranching, but I haven't seen the movie."
(LAUGHTER)
"I've heard about it."
(LAUGHTER)
"I hope you go, you know..."
(LAUGHTER)
"I hope you go back to the ranch and the farms is what I was about to say."
(LAUGHTER)
"I hadn't seen it."
(LAUGHTER)
Not what the president was expecting at a "War on Terror" event. It seemed as if Mr. Bush wanted to say more but used the cover of laughter to calculate his options and he remained cautious. The Golden Globe honored film (if you haven't heard about it) is the unconventional love story between two male ranchers. Not an easy subject for the President (and his conservative base) who oppose gay marriage.
More nuggets from the presidential Q&A session between KSU students, soldiers from nearby Fort Riley, Kansas and members of the public:
BARNEY, THE FIRST SON?
When asked how he deals with the criticism of the job, Mr. Bush cited family and faith but also drew special attention to one of his two dogs. "There's my man Barney, the little Scottish Terrier," he said. "I say this, and Laura will be furious at me, but he's the son I never had, you know."
EXERCISER IN CHIEF
In answer to that same question, the President offered up an unusual criticism aimed at the general public apathy. The President talked about his dedication to exercise. Mr. Bush said, "I work out. I try to work out five or six days a week. It's really important, if you feel that's important for your life, to schedule your life. In other words, I have trouble with people saying, 'I'm so busy I can't exercise.' I don't think you're too busy for things that are important in your life, and you can figure out ways to make time in your life."
BUSH AND BLAIR
The president was asked by a Briton in the audience about the perception of some in the UK that Prime Minister Tony Blair is a "lapdog" to Mr. Bush. In his warm defense of his friend and U.S. ally, the President indicated that he speaks to Blair once a week. The White House often does a "read out" of the President's calls but has not made public how frequently the two men speak.
"DON'T GET TOO WINDY"
President Bush must have been in a talking mood today. Despite his retelling of the First Lady's admonition, "don't get too windy," the President spoke for one hour and 40 minutes, much longer than usual. He did not even get to the anticipated headline of his message for 40 minutes, at which time he finally explained his authorization of the controversial NSA eavesdropping program. His view can be summed up with this comment: "It's amazing that people say to me, 'Well, he was just breaking the law.' If I wanted to break the law, why was I briefing Congress?"
Generally, the unscripted nature of questions apparently carries only limited political risk. It seems most who attend these functions and feel compelled to go to the microphone support him strongly. He received a dozen questions and only two had a challenging tone. One asked about education cuts and the other wanted to know when the U.S. would do something about its own weapons of mass destruction.
Several of the others openly gushed praise. The president even gently reminded the gathering that this was a "question and answer period." Still, no one asked about the NSA eavesdropping, the White House's topic of the week. Instead, the president was queried about beef imports, the crisis in Sudan, relations with China and Iran, the political troubles of British Prime Minister Tony Blair, challenges of leadership, Judge Alito's confirmation prospects, social security reform, education spending and immigration -- plus that awkward movie review moment.
"DEAD OR ALIVE"
The President also provided a little insight about the counsel and criticism he takes from the first lady. The President recalled the famous or infamous blunt reference he once made to the hunt for Osama Bin Laden: "I said some things -- "Wanted dead or alive" -- and she said, "Well, you might be able to express yourself a little better than that."
Mr. Bush also achieved an unusual crowd reaction, the kind of spontaneous "awwwww" you'd otherwise hear at a bridal shower as the gifts are being opened. What got him such a response? The President was speaking about the first lady and said, "I love her a lot."
Read more from Kelly O'Donnell
Journey to Samarra, Iraq
TRACKBACKS
Trackbacks are links to weblogs that reference this post. Like comments, trackbacks do not appear until approved by us. The trackback URL for this post is: http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451b0aa69e200d834723cd453ef
I'll state openly that I am Republican and conservative by nature, but I am also open-minded--to give a basic background. I voted for Bush and support him, even though there are times I disagree. But I would just like to remind the readers of this site the magnitude and gravity of his job. During 9/11, two jumbo jets slammed into the WTC's; during this incident people were throwing themselves out windows from multiple stories up to keep from being burned alive. The man carries the weight of that event on his shoulders and that he takes his responsiblities for our safety and security seriously. That is the context which his presidency will most likely be defined. So as we sit in our comfortable AC moderated abodes and type our short opinions on the man, it would be fair to keep it in perspective what he has been charged to do.
Bao Nguyen, Abilene, Texas (Sent Jan 24, 2006 2:33:13 AM)
Nothing's wrong. Nothing to see here. Please move along. Smile for the nice men in brown suits who want to take your picture...
Can we say "reality disconnect", folks? There. Knew ya could.
A typical sociological lesson often missed is *insert politician* playing (preying?) upon contemporary ideological bases to set up a (in particular)Good Christian Smokescreen wherein even the letter of this doctrine (Ten Commandments in this case) is flagrantly flouted for personal profit. Honestly, people never learn. As soon as "Gawd" and mentions of His agenda come spewing forth from the political orifice, and the public bites the hook, the rest is set in stone. Happy retirement, everyone. What? You didn't hear? We traded our future for "democracy in Iraq" (read that: coup to install CIA thug to further facilitate handing out our blood-and-sweat money *no-bid* to Carlyle subsidiaries while raping oil reserves and gouging public). Ever see "Repo Man" where Otto asks his brain dead teevee parents for money? Well, guess where Social Security went? Advice: Start burying those Mason jars...
This may be too much of a bitter pill for some, but those who sign up for active duty are usually mere numbers in a Ponzi scheme. Expendable commodities, dying so the rich can get richer (Great for the stock market, at least certain select portions of the tech sector)...is this how one would serve one's country? Sign here. please, and leave your soul with Dick Cheney. Trust me, you won't need it any more.
John Doe, Seattle, Wash (Sent Jan 24, 2006 2:17:53 AM)
Do the Bushies think we've all turned into "Stepford Wives" drinking the Cheney kool-aid? I put my trust in the American people to see through this latest example of arrogance and disregard for the constitution and values of our country.
Sheryl Wirth (Sent Jan 24, 2006 2:09:53 AM)
Do the Bushies think we've all turned into "Stepford Wives" drinking the Cheney kool-aid? I put my trust in the American people to see through this latest example of arrogance and disregard for the constitution and values of our country.
Sheryl (Sent Jan 24, 2006 2:07:19 AM)
It is so cringe inducing to watch these stupid people laugh uproariously everytime Bush makes one of his lame jokes and then cackles and snorts at his own "humor." What a sad devolution from, say, JFK's easy and elegant wit to Bush's sophomoric corn.
isabella beam (Sent Jan 24, 2006 1:36:42 AM)
When I taught school, I used to hear chanting in the schooyard when students were making a comment that reminds me of George W. It was - "Liar, liar, pants on fire." I expect him on the hot seat anytime.
Betty C, MD (Sent Jan 24, 2006 1:30:04 AM)
Frankly, I am at a loss as to where Kelly wanted to go with this post? She leads us in with promises of "a few surprises", but where's the follow-up analysis and fill I have come to expect from the MSM - the story behind the story, if you will? Kelly - we need a bit more depth in your reporting, girl - more on Barney, W's exercise regimes, and Laura's love - you know, doing the job we expect from a Sr. White House Correspondent!
Jim K, Redding, CA (Sent Jan 24, 2006 1:25:41 AM)
Excuse me! Liars are telling me that they are doing things illegaly just for my own good? No thanks!
Nguyen, Ellettsville, In. (Sent Jan 24, 2006 1:04:21 AM)
I live in kansas and i do not listen to bush because i do not trust him ,nor do I believe he has our best interests in mind with what he has done and will do in the future
mary kansas city ,kansas (Sent Jan 24, 2006 12:56:03 AM)
Why K-State? Why not Kansas (a liberal oasis in the red state)? I see little difference between speaking at K-State and speaking to a group of handpicked supporters. Now I remember why I got out of Dodge.
Mark H, Seattle, WA (Sent Jan 24, 2006 12:39:58 AM)
I am a student at K-State and attended the lecture today. In response to some of the earlier posts, the audience was not pre-selected. Tickets were distributed simply on a first-come, first-served basis. Secondly, Kansas does have a democratic governor, so perhaps we aren't as "red" as some of the earlier posts suggest. Lastly, I am somewhat disappointed in the way this has been covered in the media. They have all taken this as a PR move on the surveillance issues, but anyone who was at the speech today would not say that that was the topic, which is why, as the original blog says, he didn't talk about it until 40 minutes into the speech. The topic today was leadership, decision-making, and standing up for what you believe is right. That was what I learned from being there, not whether the NSA is right to listen to terrorists' phone calls (which, I incidentally, have no problem with). What I learned today was that President Bush is a man of great character who is not afraid to do what he thinks is best for our country, whether or not it is the most popular thing to do.
Clint Blaes, Manhattan, Kan. (Sent Jan 24, 2006 12:35:33 AM)
It seems the country has become afflicted with a possibly terminal case of apathy, Nobody even seems aware of the real issues that are reaching critical mass in allmost any area you look. Absolutely insane what we are letting these people do to this country, and the rest of the world, Benjemin Franklin I think said it best, we would inherit the type of government we deserve. Shame on us all.
jim goodiel (Sent Jan 24, 2006 12:16:06 AM)
It seems the country has become afflicted with a possibly terminal case of apathy, Nobody even seems aware of the real issues that are reaching critical mass in allmost any area you look. Absolutely insane what we are letting these people do to this country, and the rest of the world, Benjemin Franklin I think said it best, we would inherit the type of government we deserve. Shame on us all.
jim goodiel (Sent Jan 24, 2006 12:14:41 AM)
the president has one thing right: public apathy and the media's total deference to the administration will be looked upon poorly by future generations. If bill clinton only did one of the things this guy has done, he would have been crucified in front of the white house. where is edward r. murrow' succesor?
penny white (Sent Jan 23, 2006 11:52:38 PM)
Does no one have anything positive to say? I, for one, am thrilled that this President has core convictions which he is committed to following in what he believes to be the best interests of the nation--regardless of which way the wind may be blowing at any given moment. At the same time, I applaud his recent efforts to interact with the public, put a human face on administration policies, and make more of a public case for what he believes to be the necessary direction of the country. Members of both the media and radical left are so convinced that President Bush is some frightening combination of misguided and malevolent, they apparently cannot grasp the simple fact that the vast majority of middle America stands solidly behind the President and believe wholeheartedly in the direction in which he is leading! So far as the left is concerned--Bush is damned if he does, damned if he doesn't. How grateful I am that he will not allow such vitriol to dictate his policies and positions!
Christopher E. Burcham, Winston-Salem, NC (Sent Jan 23, 2006 11:51:29 PM)
I had the same impression as Ms. O'Donnell in re Bush's stuttering about for an answer to the question from the Kansas rancher with the Wisconsin cap. (Go, Badgers!) I could just see the wheels spinning like a Ford Focus in a snowbank in his head as he started several possible answers and couldn't find a way out with any of them.
Paul Berge, Sturtevant, Wis. (Sent Jan 23, 2006 11:37:25 PM)
Poor, poor Harry, he actually had the gauls to say what most Americans think. Seems like everything I am reading here is saying the same thing, isn't it? Wow, I never though the press could be had.
Tommy Jordan, Montgomery AL (Sent Jan 23, 2006 11:23:50 PM)
More typical Bush. Here's my fear, if we survive three more years, if our country survives three more years of Bush, how will we ever come back from the damage? If we impeach him, look what we'll have then...
S. Smith, Missouri (Sent Jan 23, 2006 11:16:15 PM)
A red state,screened attendance,rehearsed questions. What a farce this event was. Just the same old stay the course spin. In my opinion this administration from the top down is an abject failure. .
C. mcKinless,Ringwood,N.J. (Sent Jan 23, 2006 11:04:32 PM)
Once again, rhetoric that fits a prescribed text. What has this country come to? We look to the president as a father, a father to us and a father to the nation. It is very difficult for many, to accept the fact that our parent is an idiot! So a lot of citizens go along, believing what he says in hopes that he'll return to the family. A lost cause, unfortunately......
John Biroc (Sent Jan 23, 2006 10:55:23 PM)
President Bush has lost his sense of reality, he has the europeans mad about his policy no matter what it is, all he knows is Iraq, in the meantime New Orleans is going thru hell.
Latinoamerica is another mess, he has completely forgot our neighbors of the south, now they are to the left on their own initiative.
Luis A. Holkon Sr (Sent Jan 23, 2006 10:54:01 PM)
I thought it was great! He's doing exactly the right thing. He connects 9-11 with Iraq because ALL the countries in the region are connected in one way or another. Islamic Fundamentalism declared war on America with the hostages in Iran. 25 years later and they are still killing and attacking the US and our allies. He's doing exactly what he said he would do and that's why we elected him twice. Sorry Blue States!
Tom Wavra, Minneapolis. Minnesota (Sent Jan 23, 2006 10:52:59 PM)
Hand picked audiences are all this President can afford to appear before. He would be out of place before a group of citizens asking tough important questons.He would have a problem giving an intelligent answer
Robert Conner, Winston-Salem, N.C. (Sent Jan 23, 2006 10:30:34 PM)
I really just can't believe a word Pres Bush says anymore. I think he speaks only when his handlers tell him to and these last ditch efforts of his to prove this false only seem that much more pathetic. He might have strong personal values, but his political values would make Jesus weep (and are making millions of others cry, as well). Bush has entered into a war which has made America appear weaker. Bush has ignored the poor and working class (I don't remember Jesus working with the rich). He has pillaged the middle class pocketbook, pushed fundametalism here, while fighting it abroad, and trod all over the Constitution, civil liberties, and States' Rights. And, what ever happened to fiscal discipline? Is it 2008 yet?
Mic Platt (Sent Jan 23, 2006 10:18:02 PM)
I agree with some of the other comments I have read here, however every time I see that bush has made another speech I look for the domestic policy comments and questions on what he has to say about what is going on right here in America. I do not see how the president of the country can wholey ignore problems going on at home in favor of international problems. One particular item that I cannot believe has been touched has been the falling apart of our nations top automobile industries. Our government was tripping over itself to help the airlines in the wake of 9/11 with loans and tax concessions but nothing for the auto industry. It seems that all bush cares for is talking about the war and how he is always "justified" for everything he does because there is a war on terror. A few months ago I read an article about the growing divide between the haves and have nots in this country that disturbed me because I can see it progressing more and more every day. Where is our response and leadership to this? Bush likens the economy as a runaway freight train that nothing can stop. I say he is wrong and the end of the tracks will be closer than anyone thinks if something is not done. If he would really wake up and fix some things that really mean something to americans then I think I could be more supportive but until then I'm counting the months till the next election. I only hope there is someone out there that has not lost site of what we strive to be.
Jim Johnson Scipio Indiana (Sent Jan 23, 2006 10:05:08 PM)
SEND A COMMENT
PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to this post, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.